[Pigging by Wilfrid: February 20, 2012]
Too late. A day after posting this rave review comes the news that Masten Lake is closing. I don't know what this says about what diners want, considering that it offered a substantially better dining experience than many places in the neighborhood which are packed to the gills - and at comparable prices. What a great pity.
I just didn't expect it. I really didn't. What I expected was another storefront gastro-cupboard, packed with braying hipsters, with a line on the street outside, precious service and trendy small plates.
But no. This is a gem, an oasis, a place of peace and comfort with serious food; in fact, with some of the best plain eating I've enjoyed in a while. You should go, and go hungry.